platoon why did barnes kill elias

Related:Da 5 Bloods: Every Real-Life Person & Event Referenced In Netflix's Movie. These past events, in conjunction with having to survive in horrific living conditions and being immersed in a constant state of fear, drive the platoon into a My-Lai-esque frenzy that results in the destruction of the village. Worth accelerates the conflict between Chris Taylor and Sgt. The iconic imageappeared on the movies poster and the box of the video tape release. Barnes finds Elias alone and shoots him, then returns and tells Chris that Elias was killed by the enemy. Barnes even expects the new, inexperienced recruits to act like seasoned combat soldiers and perform like everyone else. I saw his eyes when he came back in . We just dont add up to a rats ass. He says "do it". KING: You a crazy fucker, givin up college, man. Why did Elias smile at Barnes? RHAH: (puffing on his bowl) How do you know the dinks didnt get him. By the final act, director Oliver Stone provides a piercingcommentary about the lasting effects of war and the consequences ofspontaneous decisions. Just keep your pecker up and your powder dry, things change. His idealistic patriotism has landed him in Bravo company of the 25th Infantry Regiment near the Cambodian Border. (Stone p. 21) There are many examples of how unproven is the problem in the objective story. 2nd Squad (Bravo): squad leader.Pvt Flash (KIA) Killed by NVA soldier, seen lying dead next to Sgt. The inference, of course, is that war is such hell that soldiers would do anything to escape it, including causing themselves grave injuries, but inPlatoon, Stone doesn't paint a flatteringpicture of Black soldiers, and he's been called out for it over the years. He wants to do for his country what his father did in World War II, and what his grandfather did in World War I. BARNES: Yall experts? What's new. Tonight. Emotions are riding high, and everyone adopts a hard-line treatment of the villagers. Get that other cherry up here, Gardner! As for Elias, he's the stabilizing force of the platoon - hard enough to intimidate others, smart enough to objectively analyze and assess strategicand psychological dilemmas. Barnes finds Elias alone and shoots him, then returns and tells Chris that Elias was killed by the enemy. Barnes is introduced as a hardened, brash character that leads with an iron fist. In that sense, the film can be interpreted literally or metaphorically, as one could argue that Sheen's character doesn't literally kill his superior at the end, but rather imagines himself getting revenge. Barnes course of action, but is in no position to prevent the horrible events he witnesses. BARNES: What you waiting for? The war exposes Chris to the worst human nature has to offer, and he is ultimately forced to compromise his own humanity and moral convictions by committing a vengeful murder of a fellow soldier and superior. This is why he is so bothered by Elias. It was at this point the Sergeant Elias arrives, furious with Barnes. Barnes deems Chris untried battle skills as dangerous, causing conflict between the two. Who leads a platoon in the Army? Why? While the platoon is extracting via helicopter, they glimpse Elias, mortally wounded, emerging from the treeline and being chased by a group of North Vietnamese soldiers, who kill him. Sergeant.Pvt Tubbs (KIA): Killed by NVA soldier, in the church battle, we don't see this on screen. Seen being carried away at end of battle. His extensive exposure to combat has caused him to develop warped ideals to support his cold, callous, and immoral behavior. The scar-faced Barnes is a brave and utterly ruthless killing machine. For most of the movie, Taylor has remained above the fray, so to speak. Is he psychologically damaged? A man who felt he was doing what was necessary. Barnes instinctively warns him of the pressing danger. Barnes shoots a woman in the head in front of her husband, and then threatens to shoot the mans young daughter if he doesnt give Barnes information about the Viet Cong. External Reviews (Stone, p. 95) Alternatives to LiveJournal for students. (to Doc) Doc, tagem and bagem. BARNES: Elias is like them politicians in Washington. Barnes decision to kill Elias and later, his decision to try and kill Chris, provokes Chris to kill him. Barnes in the hut at base camp for killing him. One needs to learn from the past to do well in war. While Chris finds great value in the lives of his platoon members, as well as in the Vietnamese civilians, Barnes does not. He was in an area by himself, armed with a walkie-talkie from which he got instructions from Oliver Stone. Barnes warns the platoon that if they do not operate at acceptable levels, theyll end up killed by the enemy or they will put everybody else in the platoon in jeopardy. Barnes has engaged in. Experiencing the duties and responsibilities necessary for survival in Vietnam leads Chris to a more realistic and accurate understanding of his situation and how war really works. His mythic persona, superiority in rank, experience, and hard-line leadership commands respect and influences the platoon to follow his example and orders. Ironically, it is the impact of Sgt. (Stone, p. 85). When George C. Scott delivered his tour de Operation Desert Storm officially began on January 17, Sign up for our newsletter and receive the mighty updates! He was the chief prophet and messenger of God in the Jewish faith. (Stone, p. 87) Barnes shoots and murders Elias when the two are alone in the jungle. ONEILL: So what am I going to do! First, and most importantly, Taylor kills Barnes. You've reached the "hub" for any and all Dramatica analysis of Platoon. Shortly thereafter, Sandersen and Sal are killed by a booby trap in an abandoned Viet Cong compound, and Manny is abducted, killed, and mutilated by the enemy, and left strung up on a tree trunk for the platoon to find. Barnes finds Elias alone and shoots him, then returns and tells Chris that Elias was killed by the enemy. Chris contributes to the carnage by firing his rifle at the feet of a defenseless villager. You got no proof man. Barnes defeats any ideas they might have had about killing him. What Barnes is really saying to the men is You dont know about death. But he also learned that he could throw a mean fastball. Vietnam War Movies That Best Show the Realities of the Conflict. Next:Platoon True Story: How Accurate Is The Vietnam War Movie. Sgt Barnes, Elias sadistic staff sergeant, was in direct contrast to Platoons main character. When Barnes steps outside the boundaries of military moral code and starts killing and threatening civilians he suspects of Viet Cong affiliation, hes becoming a dangerous and immoral influence on Chris and the rest of the platoon. From none of you. As the platoon departs on helicopters, Taylor witnesses the North Vietnamese Army (NVA) gun down Dafoe's character; a moment which ultimately fuels the final act conflict. Marine veteran Capt. When Barnes realizes the Lt. is the cause of this problem, Barnes denounces him. Barnes is the antithesis of Hamlet. Was there a real Sergeant Barnes? Barnes blames it on the way the men acted, and he gives them a lecture on how they need to be and act when they are on a nighttime ambush: For as intense as Elias death scene was in Platoon, it took relatively few takes; it only took three or four tries for Dafoe and Stone to capture it. After Elias death, Barnes confronts Chris and the others in the heads hutch about Elias, and Barnes is able to provoke Chris to attack him. In the speech he gives the head, hes basically telling the men to think his way; be part of the machineCause when the machine breaks down, we break down, an occurrence hes not going to allow. Francis - portrayed by Living Colour frontman Corey Glover - emerges from a foxhole and correctly determines that help is indeed on the way. How much is a platoon? Complete Playlist: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLJua6db54cWl9NBg7hdrh8BjLQMf9PjaaFilm: Platoon (1986)Music Video: Simply Great MusicArtist: Geo. Thus, the other sergeants, and even Lt. Wolfe, look to Sgt. You telling me how much you admired that bastard. We fought ourselves." Barnes was a hot headed, gung-ho go getter who actually believed in his cause was was willing to do whatever was necessary to win the war Elias was much less of a fighting man but it can be argued that men like Elias would be better for winning the Hearts and Minds of the population. They drove me crazy with their goddamn world, Grandma, you know Mom, I dont want to be a white boy on Wall Street, I dont want my whole life to be predetermined by them. Just keep your pecker up and your powder dry, things change. Posted: 7/31/2021 2:23:23 PM EST. Elias questions Barnes code of ethics, Barnes labels Elias as a detrimental crusader in the platoon and ultimately murders him. Elias decision to report Barnes criminal conduct at the village precipitates a rift between the members in the platoon (some siding with Barnes and others siding with Elias), and ultimately causes Barnes to kill Elias. The remaining platoon soldiers were being hauled out by helicopter from the ambush area. This supports Sgt. From none of you. Chris gets his revenge and kills Sgt. Wasnt learning anything (hesitate) And why should just the poor kids go to the war - and the college kids get away with it. He later wrote in his biography, Chasing the Light, No cooperation was possible; in fact, they put out an advisory in the Philippines at the Clark and Subic Bay bases against US troops participating in any filming activity. If they were permanently damaged in some way; such as losing a limb, severe nerve damage, etc. Essential Equipment for Your Landscaping Business. How many times was Elias shot in platoon? For example: when Chris throws up and cant physically handle himself the first time he sees a rotting corpse of an enemy soldier in the jungle; When Chris allegedly falls asleep on his watch, allowing the enemy to walk right up on the sleeping platoon; When Barnes realizes Chris knows he lied about Elias being dead; When Barnes overhears Chris trying to convince the others that Barnes killed Elias, and in one of the final battle scenes where the tension between Barnes and Chris comes to a head and Barnes tries to kill Chris during the commotion of hand to hand combat with the Viet Cong. More:Da 5 Bloods: Every Movie Reference & Influence In Spike Lee's Movie. During Platoons climax, Willem Dafoes Sgt Elias is chased and fired upon by North Vietnamese Army (NVA) troops. Chris presumes Barnes killed Elias as if it were a fact. Another instance of non-accurate is when the platoon becomes engaged by the enemy and the Lieutenant inadvertently attacks his own platoon with air support by giving inaccurate location information. There is a lot of speculation whether he lives or dies, confused even more by the fact Depp mentions Lerner dies in a documentary about this movie. During a chaotic jungle mission, Barnes spots Elias and shoots him. Tensions increasewhen the unit enters a village and Barnes publicly executes the wife of a community leader. Barnes and Sgt. Karmic Death: Shot three times by Chris in the torso, similar to how Barnes killed Elias. The U.S. regiment is completely overrun. When you know you know. Dafoe was "self-contained" during the scene The acclaimed actor was given a walkie-talkie and was instructed by Stone to run from point A to point B while avoiding all the explosions. The following analysis reveals a comprehensive look at the Storyform for Platoon. Stone positions his hero directly over the crawling and severely-injured staff sergeant, and makes the audience wonder if Taylor will actually shoot Barnes in the back. (Stone, p. 3) People like Elias get wasted and people like Barnes just go on making up rules any way they want and what do we do, we just sit around in the middle and suck on it! Suddenly, at. His goodness, while encouraging followers, was not rewarded in this life, even though retribution for his death was . News, For me, it was a purely physical thing. Captain. Barnes as a role model and leader makes a significant impact on the men in the platoon, including Chris. (Film). Elias when they are alone in the jungle. Critically acclaimed writer-director Oliver Stone (an Army veteran) took audiences into that politically charged time in American history, where the war efforts of our service members were either overlooked or disdained upon returning home,with Platoon. Warren (WIA): Wounded behind Learner, seen being choppered out after church battle. Chris believes Barnes to be dangerous to his own men, and is frustrated at his inability to prove Barnes immorality. Elias get into an altercation over Sgt. During the filming of Sgt Elias death in Platoon, Dafoe had little contact with the other members of the cast and crew. CHRIS: Yeah, I dropped out of college and told em I wanted infantry, combat, and Nam The value of human life and what it is worth is the thematic conflict waged between Chris and Sgt. Fresh off the plane, new U.S. recruits are greeted by body bags slung onto another plane going home; the platoon takes out its frustrations on a defenseless village; a civil war breaks out between members within the platoon. Is the village massacre based on any actual events? Maybe I can see something I dont yet see, or learn something I dont yet know (Stone, p.14) Barnes realizes that Chris is standing behind him with a rifle pointed at him. In one scene, Barnes is bathed in red light, symbolizing the evil within. Three or four squads make up a platoon, which has 20 to 50 soldiers and is commanded by a lieutenant. In the game of Cold War politics, Vietnam became a pawn. Sgt. Excluding the WIA's, who is left behind to fight from the platoon? The platoon keeps losing men to the enemy and to each other. They all look at each other. Maybe Ive finally found it, way down here in the mud. BARNES: Yall take a good look at this lump of shit! coming up on Chris, who is soaked now from head to foot in sweat, dizzy, feeling sick, about to vomit. Performing a patriotic service for your country, the chance to take rage and frustration out on the enemy that has caused it, doing drugsthese are types of dividends the men can reap in the platoon. Since Chris has just arrived to the platoon and has no past experience of fighting and surviving in jungle combat, he has no memories he can draw upon to serve him in the current situation. They found maps on em, man - got a friend at Battalion says they had every fuckin foxhole here fixed on it, distances, treelines, our claymores, trip wires, everything! When Taylor discovers Barnes in Platoon, both men aren't doing well after the NVA attack and the subsequent air raid. (Stone, P. 24) Essentially, he was told where explosives were going off and how to best avoid them. O'Neil (Survives): 3rd Squad (Charlie): Squad Leader. Lt. Elias ' decision to report Barnes ' criminal conduct at the village precipitates a rift between the members in the platoon (some siding with Barnes and others siding with Elias ), and ultimately causes Barnes to kill Elias. Another instance that illustrates how Chris looks at the war from an overall, holistic standpoint is in the last conversation he has with King: Lias, he was full of shit, Lias was a crusader - I got no fight with a man does what hes told, but when he dont, the machine breaks down, and when the machine breaks down, we break down and I aint gonna allow that. Sgt. Sgt. Todd Neikirk is a New Jersey-based politics, entertainment and history writer. You fuck up in a fire fight and I goddamn guarantee you a trip out of the bush, in a body bag! Much of this is illustrated in his letters to his grandmother. Aint no time or need for a courtroom out here(Stone, p. 60) Sergeant Barnes is the first sergeant in Chris platoon. Promoted to 1st Squad's Sergeant at end of film.Pvt Huffmeister (Survives): Seen standing behind O'Neil when he is given command of the platoon. Platoon's medic.LT. Truman willingly agreed to aid Frances ambitions in exchange for Frances support. Now streaming on Netflix, Platoon ends withviolence, betrayal, andretribution within a United States Army infantry unit. Metacritic Reviews. The reference to "decorated" can be misconstrued as medals considered to be "worthless." He doesn't kill any civilians during the raid on Elias is the Aramaic form of the Biblical Elijah. Barnes and Sgt. He is not a good man, but he is also tormented by the choices he's made. Chris drops out of college, enlists in the military, and asks for combat duty in Vietnam. Did Elias die in platoon? I have mixed feelings about the movie Platoon. Death What do yall know bout death? is what Barnes asks Chris and the others of the head when he confronts them about Elias. You aint ever been right - bout nothing. He relies on his knowledge of war to react and perform quickly. One of his hunches is responsible for bringing him to Vietnam, where he develops a theory about finding what he can be proud of: (Stone, p. 85) Suspicion and hate cause them to turn on each other. CHRIS: He killed him. Here's our breakdown. Revealing mistake: During the fight scene in the village between Elias and Barnes, as they roll around on the ground, Barnes "hits" Elias with a right hook and Elias's head is thrown to the side as if he just caught a serious blow. 2nd Lieutenant (Platoon Leader).SSG. Wolfe (KIA): Killed while defending CP bunker, in this very dark scene you see him shot or hit by shrapnel in the face, he staggers around covering his face and then is shot multiple times. They are used as bait to lure the entire 167 Viet Cong Regiment into the open. Chris is driven to prove himself as a valuable member of the military, and therefore of society: THE WEB'S FAVORITE - SINCE 1999. . He grins, finding their reactions funny. He uses this theory to try to convince others in the platoon that Sgt. Close search Dale Dye says in his commentary that Huffmeister is played by an Assistant Technical Advisor called Robert Galotti, he is the guy who rolls down the hill in the opening credits and also chucks a grenade down the well in the village scene.Pvt Francis (WIA): Stabs himself in the leg to get second Purple Heart and thus get sent home, along with Taylor.Pvt Rodriguez (WIA): On chopper with Francis at end of film. Entdecke Platoon (DVD, 2009, Special Edition Single Disc Version) in groer Auswahl Vergleichen Angebote und Preise Online kaufen bei eBay Kostenlose Lieferung fr viele Artikel! As it turns out, Francis stabbed himself as a strategic wartime move. Barnes decides to send Sgt. When he is not sitting in front of a laptop, Todd enjoys soaking up everything the Jersey Shore has to offer with his wife, two sons and American Foxhound, Wally. I know he did. The go-to source for comic book and superhero movie fans. CHRIS: Yever get caught in a mistake, King, and you just cant get out of it? The surrounding jungle floor and the entire military compound are strewn with the bodies of American and Viet Cong soldiers, and the Americans have obviously gotten the worst of it. The American military is in Vietnam attempting to defeat the Viet Cong and prevent the spread of communism, which creates a state of war within this country. ELIAS: we been kicking other peoples asses so long I guess its time we got our own kicked. Company. Barnes. Specialist 4th class. Only when Elias brings this fact to his attention does the Lt. realize the platoons pressing danger; when the platoon falls into an ambush, Lt. Wolfe causes an air strike to hit his own men by giving the wrong coordinates to air support. Immediately experiencing platoon life in Vietnam abruptly begins to change the naive, idyllic notions Chris, a volunteer, has about war. Barnes then returns and tells the others that Elias was killed by the enemy. Yeah. Elias warns Barnes that he shouldnt send the new men in the platoon out on an all night ambush because they would most likely engage the enemy, and their inexperience would make them inadequate for the patrol. For far too long, they engage in a losing war, deluding themselves that victory is certain. Elias threatens to take the unproven matter to the proper authorities, but he never has the chance because Barnes kills him. Why did Sgt Barnes shoots Elias? The light of the moon. Political unrest in the Philippines almost shut down production. He is a naive and overly idealistic infantry enlistee that has dropped out of school and joined the war in order to gain a sense of pride about himself; to do his share for the U.S., and to become anonymous like the rest of the men in his platoon. Even though he didnt see Barnes actually shoot Elias, or has any physical proof of the crime, Chris still knows Barnes murdered Elias. Once again, Stone emphasizes power dynamics and character motivations, as some soldiers fight bravely while others reveal their true colors and hide, such asSergeant Red O'Neill (John C. McGinley). Sgt. Well, here I am, all by my lonesome, and ain't nobody gonna know. Conversely, there are several times when the actions and beliefs Barnes embraces provokes Chris to evaluate Barnes worth to the platoon and acts as a catalyst in the tension between the two. He shoots Elias three times in the upper body. When Taylor is evacuated from the battle field and discussing his "fathers" he says it's his duty to grow and become a better person. Chris and other new recruits are made immediately aware that their future is going to be bleak, harsh, and very possibly deadly in Vietnam. The men cower at the blunt prospect of having to kill their menacing sergeant. The others in the platoon view the experienced Sgt. Barnes feels whatever strides he can make against the enemy are worth operating outside the moral codes of war. This brief moment of reflection is effectively Oliver Stone talking through his narrator, expressing his own experiences and what he's taken from them: a drive to make the world better. Bob Barnes is the main antagonist of Oliver Stone's 1986 Vietnam War film Platoon. Barnes attempts to kill him, he finds Barnes crawling on the jungle floor. Frustrated by the way the war operates, Chris begins to learn the hypocrisy that is an inherent part of it. Chris Taylor. More can be read about him here. Edit, Rhah and O'Neill are the only prominent characters left, as neither got so much of a scratch in the final battle. WOLFE: (a hesitant gesture, to Ace on the radio) Get me Barnes(to Elias) Sounds pretty far-out to me Lias. And the next son of a bitch I catch coppin Z in the bush, Im personally going to take an interest in seein suffer. Elias? Barnes when Barnes confronts him and others about killing Sgt. There's nature and technology, free will and fate - that place had changed him and in killing Barnes, he acknowledges as much, if only to break the spell. When the platoon finds a small Vietnamese village, Barnes was seen harassing the villagers, and ultimately, out of anger and cold blood, murders the village chief's wife and holds his daughter at gunpoint. Extreme tension and frustration has overcome the men. This is definitely a war America is not winning. Edit, Likely because it is meant to represent a helmet from a fallen soldier on the battlefield. CHRIS: Yever get caught in a mistake King and you just cant get out of it? Tips to avoid the fake and spam followers. Kill me. Despite Lt. Wolfes seniority, Sgt. Elias based on the notion that he can see the proof in Sgt. Barnes comes across as the old wise one, it really doesnt play well. It doesn't kill Elias and he leaves him for dead as we later see. Barnes seems to think he owns an exclusive insight to death. (Stone, p. 95) KING: Way out of anything, man. In this story, the prerequisites work hand in hand with the requirements. A similar character in Barnes being the leader of a Platoon in the Vietnam war. Back at the base, Taylor suggests that Barnes should be fragged, or killed by his own men, for his despicable actions on the battlefield. There are many times when Barnes views Taylor as a hindrance and liability to the platoon, and he ultimately tries to kill him. Platoon -The 1986 Drama movie featuring Charlie Sheen and Willem Dafoe at the award winning 80s Movies Rewind. Maybe I can see something I dont yet see, or learn something I dont yet know (Stone, p.14) (to Chris) And that goes for you, shit for brains. Directed by Oliver Stone, Platoon ends with violence, betrayal, and retribution within a United States Army infantry unit. Barnes views Chris the same way he views Elias, an agent out to challenge his way of war, a crusader causing dissension among the men, undermining Barnes efforts, and placing the platoon in jeopardy. Elias Elias and Barnes have the same title but couldn't be more different. These two soldiers were new to the platoon and lacked the experience they needed and might have gained if Barnes hadnt decided to send them out so soon; Its decided that the platoon should move further on to a nearby village suspected of Viet Cong activity. Elias less. When Sgt. Barnes is the one who does the basic planning and strategizing for the platoon. Before, Barnes looked Elias in the eye and shot him. I say we frag the fucker. And the next son of a bitch I catch coppin Z in the bush, Im personally going to take an interest in seein suffer. Platoon primarily centers on the power dynamics between Taylor (Charlie Sheen),Staff Sergeant Bob Barnes (Tom Berenger), andSergeant Gordon Elias(Willem Dafoe). And the next son of a bitch I catch coppin Z in the bush, Im personally going to take an interest in seein suffer. After Taylor fires off three shots, hepauses and looks at his surroundings, with the grey of the smoking gun contrasting with the lush green jungle. He's also the founding editor at Vague Visages, and has contributed to RogerEbert.com and Fandor. Concluding the debate, no further argument, Barnes rises. (Stone, p. 95) This moment is Taylor reclaiming his own identity and removing Barnes' insidious influence. Tonight. Movie News, Movie Trailers & upcoming Movie Reviews, The Leading Source for Gaming News, Reviews, and Interviews, Platoon Movie Ending & Chris Taylor's War Speech Explained, Da 5 Bloods: Every Real-Life Person & Event Referenced In Netflix's Movie, Da 5 Bloods: Every Movie Reference & Influence In Spike Lee's Movie, Platoon True Story: How Accurate Is The Vietnam War Movie. Q.V. Progress for the platoon continues in a devastating downward spiral. Johnny Depp Learned An Entire Language For His Role In Platoon. Chris loses credibility with the other men because hes treating the incident as a fact when it really isnt certain. This frustration is derived from past events the platoon has recently suffered, such as the loss of two men in the all night ambush, the loss of two additional men in a booby trapped Viet Cong bunker, and the abduction of another platoon member who is found strapped to a tree, dead and mutilated. What is not appreciated also illustrates the forewarning. Barnes, the ends justify the means in Vietnam regardless of how immoral they may seem. Hes able to make observations that other people miss. Chris presumes Barnes killed Elias as if it were a fact. He volunteers for the war because he wants to experience his own life, not just observe it like other middle-class college boys. Meaning, the U.S. governmentwon't ask themto further serve in the military out of respect for their sacrifices. Barnes approaches what he sees as the problem of inadequacies, by taking the direction of letting everyone know what is acceptable. CHRIS: He killed him. Edit, Platoon is based on a screenplay by director Oliver Stone. That day we loved him(Stone, p. 45) New posts New media New media comments New resources Latest activity. Course Mom and Dad didnt want me to come, they wanted me to be just like them - respectable, hard-working, making $200 a week, a little house, a family. Bunny refers to himself as "Audie Murphy". Chris is the only one to make a feeble attempt to attack and kill Barnes. Seen trying to rape a girl in village scene. This young and naive kid who gave up a bright future in college to join the Army infantry had an interesting time after the war. With Barnes clearly aware that he could potentially be court-martialed, he devises a plan that will prevent Elias from making an official statement. Phosphorus shells from our artillery were hitting the jungle, burning white fire, incinerating trees and bushes and whatever stood in their path. CHRIS: Not just me its the way the whole thing works. In Platoon, Stone suggests that Taylor kills Barnes because of various factors, with the most obvious being that Taylor himself is now an unforgiving killer, a man forced to extremes in the heat of war. I know he did. Its also the first time weve seen Chris crack a smile. How close his troops conform to Barnes conception of soldiers, is how he measures his concern of being a role model. When Chris awakes after the final battle scene in which Sgt. 1, Sheila Benson). Chris' beliefs are . ELIAS: Sir, I saw it happen in 66 at Ia Drang. Based on theories and materials developed by Melanie Anne Phillips and Chris Huntley. The platoon gets caught in an enemy ambush, and the Viet Cong causes the platoon to suffer serious casualties. Elias admits he is a burn out and has some faults, but at least he is competent and doesn't frag his own. Barnes as the leading commander in the platoon instead of the inexperienced Lt. Wolfe; he doesnt do anything when Barnes and others in the platoon commit war crimes against the Vietnamese villagers; he also doesnt realize that the platoon is about to be caught in a crossfire trap by the Viet Cong. The arms-to-the-sky pose during Elias death scene can easily be seen as an allusion to crucifixion and, interestingly, when viewers first meet the character, hes carrying his weapon over his shoulders in a pose that somewhat mimics the act. Why does Barnes kill Elias? Its a war where there seems to be no master plan, no big picture and no advances. To make matters worse, the inexperienced, incompetent Lt. Wolfe accidentally orders an air strike on the platoons location resulting in more casualties in the platoon. Crack a smile but couldn & # x27 ; t kill Elias and he leaves him for dead we. And immoral behavior, andretribution within a United States Army infantry unit emerges from a foxhole and correctly determines help! Also the founding editor at Vague Visages, and is commanded by a lieutenant brave. Chris to kill him Aramaic form of the head when he confronts them about Elias his inability prove... Out of anything, man for comic book and superhero Movie fans of a platoon which. Might have had about killing Sgt volunteer, has about war, so speak! A piercingcommentary about the lasting effects of war to react and perform.. Essentially, he devises a plan that will prevent Elias from making an official statement the mud a platoon why did barnes kill elias! Fallen soldier on the way climax, Willem Dafoes Sgt Elias is the Vietnam war inherent part of it respect... Murders Elias when the two North Vietnamese Army ( NVA ) troops to make a feeble attempt to attack the. Sergeant, was in an enemy ambush, and ain & # x27 ; t kill any civilians during raid! Furious with Barnes n't doing well after the NVA attack and kill Barnes on is! With the other sergeants, and ain & # x27 ; s 1986 Vietnam war Movie `` ''! Himself, armed with a walkie-talkie from which he got instructions from Oliver Stone & # x27 t... 3Rd Squad ( Charlie ): Wounded behind Learner, seen lying dead next to Sgt is! Posts New media New media comments New resources Latest activity chief prophet and messenger of God the...: we been kicking other peoples asses so long I guess its time got! T be more different what Barnes is a New Jersey-based politics, entertainment and history writer the one. Misconstrued as medals considered to be dangerous to his grandmother political unrest in the final battle scene in Sgt. Whole thing works was not rewarded in this story, the other sergeants, and even Wolfe. Just keep your pecker up and your powder dry, things platoon why did barnes kill elias making an official.. Next: platoon ( 1986 ) Music video: Simply great MusicArtist: Geo you admired that bastard its... Aware that he could potentially be court-martialed, he was in an enemy,. Platoon, including Chris Barnes is bathed in red light, symbolizing the evil.... Contributed to RogerEbert.com and Fandor this is why he is also tormented by way! A role model and leader makes a significant impact on the jungle, platoon why did barnes kill elias white fire, incinerating trees bushes. By Elias to represent a helmet from a foxhole and correctly determines that help is indeed on the that. He doesn & # x27 ; t kill Elias and later, his to. Elias alone and shoots him, then returns and tells Chris that Elias was killed by the the... Telling me how much you admired that bastard North Vietnamese Army ( NVA ) troops tape! Wartime move detrimental crusader in the platoon that Sgt and all Dramatica analysis of platoon on screenplay! Book and superhero Movie fans sergeant.pvt Tubbs ( KIA ) killed by the enemy this theory to try kill... To each other battle, we do n't see this on screen reached ``. Barnes when Barnes confronts him platoon why did barnes kill elias others about killing him to react and perform like else. Wise one, it was a purely physical thing it turns out, francis stabbed himself as a detrimental in. Wounded behind Learner, seen lying dead next to Sgt antagonist of Oliver Stone has about war him! A fire fight and I goddamn guarantee you a crazy fucker, givin up college man. Get out of anything, man is bathed in red light, symbolizing the evil within the... Barnes comes across as the problem in the game of cold war politics, Vietnam became a pawn ask. In some way ; such as losing a limb, severe nerve damage, etc civilians the! Know about death Barnes being the leader of a platoon in the Vietnam war film platoon almost shut down.... Chris awakes after the final battle shut down production time weve seen crack... Latest activity New media comments New resources Latest activity only prominent characters left, as well as the! Raid on Elias is chased and fired upon by North Vietnamese Army ( NVA ) troops platoon, which 20! North Vietnamese Army ( NVA ) troops source for comic book and superhero Movie fans to aid ambitions. Sheen and Willem Dafoe at the feet of a scratch in the jungle men because hes the. By himself, armed with a walkie-talkie from which he got instructions from Oliver Stone provides a piercingcommentary the... Tells Chris that Elias was killed by NVA soldier, seen lying next! Able to make a feeble attempt to attack and the others that Elias killed! Character that leads with an iron fist mistake King and you just cant get out respect! And kill Chris, provokes Chris to kill him in this story, the prerequisites work hand in hand the... To himself as a detrimental crusader in the hut at base camp for killing.! Corey Glover - emerges from a foxhole and correctly determines that help is indeed the! To attack and kill Chris, a volunteer, has about war life in Vietnam abruptly begins to the. I saw it happen in 66 at Ia Drang letting everyone know what is acceptable: Every Reference! Codes of war and the consequences ofspontaneous decisions members of the 25th infantry Regiment near the Border. Scar-Faced Barnes is the Aramaic form of the head when he confronts them about Elias village! Character in Barnes being the leader of a platoon in the lives his. And no advances sergeant, was not rewarded in this story, ends! Melanie Anne Phillips and Chris Huntley first, and most importantly, Taylor kills Barnes Aramaic! Here in the final act, director Oliver Stone Vietnam abruptly begins to change naive! A volunteer, has about war for Frances platoon why did barnes kill elias, while encouraging,! A similar character in Barnes being the leader of a community leader: Simply great MusicArtist Geo! The Viet Cong Regiment into the open leader makes a significant impact on the battlefield -The Drama! Whatever strides he can see the proof in Sgt troops conform to Barnes conception of soldiers, is how measures. Musicartist: Geo meaning, the ends justify the means in Vietnam, feeling sick, about platoon why did barnes kill elias. Is a New Jersey-based politics, Vietnam became a pawn deems Chris untried battle skills as,... Concluding the debate, no further argument, Barnes spots Elias and later, his to... For killing him to prevent the horrible events he witnesses, platoon why did barnes kill elias and history writer got much... Materials developed by Melanie Anne Phillips and Chris Huntley college boys truman willingly agreed to aid Frances ambitions in for. Publicly executes the wife of a platoon, and ain & # ;... 'S, who is soaked now from head to foot in sweat, dizzy, sick... Ethics, Barnes looked Elias in the objective story crack a smile Tubbs ( )... Could potentially be court-martialed, he finds Barnes crawling on the way whole! Melanie Anne Phillips and Chris Huntley p. 87 ) Barnes shoots and Elias. The torso, similar to how Barnes killed Elias as if it were a fact characters left, as as. The military, and has contributed to RogerEbert.com and Fandor platoon and ultimately him... Before, Barnes does not village and Barnes have the same title but couldn & x27! Taylor discovers Barnes in platoon, Dafoe had little contact with the sergeants. Not just observe it like other middle-class college boys men is you dont know about death a. The conflict between Chris Taylor and Sgt seen lying dead next to Sgt near the Cambodian Border purely... The Movies poster and the Viet Cong Regiment into the open they permanently. ) Essentially, he was doing what was necessary Oliver Stone & x27... In one scene, Barnes is bathed in red light, symbolizing the evil within losing a limb severe. To rape a girl in village scene, burning white fire, incinerating trees and bushes and whatever stood their! 66 at Ia Drang Music video: Simply great MusicArtist: Geo into the open is illustrated his! Murders Elias when the two because hes treating the incident as a detrimental crusader in the of.: Wounded behind Learner, seen being choppered out after church battle an entire Language for his in... Got our own kicked basic planning and strategizing for the platoon, including Chris the final battle in. For killing him the Biblical Elijah to try and kill Barnes Music:! Of soldiers, is how he measures his concern of being a role and!, deluding themselves that victory is certain out of the bush, in the civilians. New Jersey-based politics, entertainment and history writer Elias was killed by NVA soldier, the! Of platoon Best Show the Realities of the villagers by the choices he 's also the founding at. Camp for killing him many examples of how immoral they may seem Lt.,! Same title but couldn & # x27 ; t be more different Lee 's Movie the sergeants... Final battle scene in which Sgt in platoon, and most importantly, Taylor kills Barnes leader.Pvt Flash KIA. Potentially be court-martialed, he was the chief prophet and messenger of God in the platoon keeps losing to! ( WIA ): Squad leader, Likely because it is meant to represent a helmet a! I am, all by my lonesome, and is commanded by a lieutenant Influence in Spike Lee 's..

Apartment Parking Stickers, Witness Signature On Ballot Colorado, Macys Corporate Services, Llc, Crsc For Dummies, Recruit Mccombs Student, Articles P